Transition Towns Forum » TransitionGroup: Cities

the problems of Cities compared to Towns

(6 posts)

Tags:

  1. The experience we've had so far in Brighton is that raising awareness of transition towns in cities is quite different from doing so in small towns. In smaller places if you put on a talk or a film you can be pretty sure you will get an audience that is a greater proportion of the population of your town than in a city, because the talk or film will be a much more visible event, maybe even the only thing going on that week. In a city there is so many more events to compete with.

    We've held a few events so far but may have made the mistake of thinking that because we put them on, people will come. So one suggestion I want to make at the moment is a new approach to holding events – that we don't just put them on, advertise them and hope that people will come. Instead I think there should be connections made with particular organisations who are invited to the event. Perhaps an event is particularly tailored towards schools, for example, with invitations to the environmental clubs at schools to come and take part (most schools have one of these now). Or teaming up with an existing venture that's trying to do the same thing.

    In my opinion this is the way that cities overcome the problems of awareness raising, because although it is difficult to raise the profile of transition towns above the clamour of everything else going on, cities have in their favour that there are many other already existing enterprises that we can connect with.

    Posted 1 year ago #
  2. RuthWallsgrove
    Member

    That sounds like very good advice.

    Our thinking it to organise events through existing permaculture, green, community groups - plus interested companies, student groups and other kinds of organisations. If we let everyone we're individually in touch with know we are prepared to stand up at one of their meetings, or give a short presentation, or a lunchtime talk, our sense is we'll have enough takers .. to try out all the material on, for a start! I think many organisations want topics, speakers.

    warm wishes
    Ruth

    Posted 1 year ago #
  3. HJG
    Member

    Hi

    I am not sure that city have problems particularly but they are different and when you scale anything up, it is needs careful handling.

    We are only just starting in Leeds, but my early impression is that people who are settled relate very much more easily to their local community than to the city as a whole. Trying to get their heads round the idea of Transition for a city of 750,000 is just too much. So I think it will be very much easier in communities of 5-10K as long as we really work on the networking.

    We also have is some large (50K plus) transient populations, mainly of students and young people on 6 month lets who move around the city frequently. Engaging them will be harder, although many of the universities and colleges are mulling in some way or another.

    There are already a lot of people who already know one another and go to the same raft of sustainable/green/environmental groups, so we are trying to attract people from outside those areas.

    The initial group in my area is large, with another large group on one side and small groups on the other side and nearer to town (the latter for funding reasons). A member of one of the small groups pointed out that given our location, the group I belong to could act as an incubator for areas nearby, including his own. A member of the group nearer town is worried that our large group will just go off into the wide blue yonder and leave less advantaged neighbours behind. And several members of our group are want to join up with our neighbours because they can see that we have a lot of advantages in terms of people and resources and want to share them! So there is some sharing to do.

    Personally, I can see a lot of resistance from local people in some areas if we parachute in and and think it will be a lot better for the initiative to be seen to be coming from the local communities. What we can do is provide support and logistical help to our neighbours. I also anticpate that when we get awareness sessions going locally, we can work together to attract a small number of people from the neighbouring areas and then we can re-direct them to their local group and beef up our neighbours.

    On the other hand, we are not going to be able to tackle things like engagement with local government, transport or planning at neighbourhood level, so city wide groups will be essential. My own view is that it wil also be essential that those involved be activley involved at community level as well, so we do not get a them and us situation.

    Does that make any sense?

    Posted 1 year ago #
  4. Hi everyone,I'm a co-conspirator with Ruth Wallsgrove in the Sydney (Aust) region. As Ruth mentioned in her post we have been thinking that our best approach will be through existing organisations. We have set our focus on what we call the "Greater Sydney Area" also known as the Sydney Basin. This has something like 30+ local shires and councils and a population of around 4 million all up. To us, trying to go direct to people in neighbourhoods does not seem to be a viable option.Our aim is to facilitate and support local community groups to engage with their local councils and start down the path of energy descent planning. As well as other organisations such as Permaculture, Alternative Technology and Food Fairness who are already on the same wavelength as us we have existing connections with community and resident groups in our own suburbs. We'll soon be putting all this to the test and will let you know of our experiences as we go!

    Posted 1 year ago #
  5. Hi,

    I'm part of the steering group for Transition Norwich ( www.transitionnorwich.org ). We're thinking along similar lines as above - i.e. reaching out to existing groups. And not necessarily just green groups; also faith groups and community groups. Our idea was to offer to give short presentations to groups either in one of their meetings, or by putting on a talk for them.

    As Norwich has a population of about 120,000, we are also thinking that we will probably end up as a coordinating hub dealing with city-wide issues, with separate groups branching out for different areas. By getting people's postcodes along with their interests at sign-up, we hope to facilitate getting people who live in close proximity in touch with each other.

    At the moment we are just starting our awareness raising stage, with a launch planned for the autumn. We are hoping for big things, given the reputation for Norwich as a Green city!

    Greg

    Posted 1 year ago #
  6. citrus
    Member

    in swansea we are planning a 'peak oil tour' - a short interactive event that we can take out to schools, community groups, women's institutes and anyone else who'll have us! this will be an introduction to the concept of peak oil as we are aware that many people haven't even heard the term.

    while this sort of thing is essential i realy feel part of the transition process is realising that we are not responsible for educating the whole city - i think our energy would be better used getting others interested and leeting the workload be spread amongst many. ultimately the majority need to be involved for transition to happen...

    hannah xx

    Posted 1 year ago #

RSS feed for this topic

Reply

You must log in to post.